Who are UK banks lending to?

One of the big component of the (currently forthcoming) research by Andrew Baker, Gerald Epstein and Juan Montecino is a factor called “misallocation costs” — that is, the costs that the distorted incentives prevalent in the financial sector inflict on the wider British economy.   One of the big factors of misallocation is the distortion of lending. Financial institutions seem to far prefer to lend to whizzy financial schemes than to lend to the rest of the economy.

It’s quite hard on a casual search to find out how much money UK-resident banks lend to the various different sectors of the economy, even though this is one of the most important measures of the usefulness of the City of London to the UK economy.

But it is possible, if you squirrel down into the Bank of England’s data, to construct a picture of what’s going on. The outcome isn’t pretty. Here’s a graph showing what’s going on: I’ve constructed it from a Bank series entitled C1.2, and called “Industrial analysis of monetary financial institutions’ lending to UK residents.”  Here’s the graph.

This kind of speaks for itself. (I used data from December 2017, and I was careful to scroll down to the third row in the data series, “Amounts outstanding of lending in all currencies.”)

One pull-out quote for me here is that manufacturing made up just 3.5 percent of all business lending by UK banks. Meanwhile, lending for financial intermediation plus “financial intermediation auxiliary companies” (such as central clearing) made up over 60 percent of all lending.  This isn’t bombshell new information – the experts know of this, and I discuss it in my forthcoming book – but it’s still useful to have the update and the graph.

Which raises a question I pose early in my book: “What is it all for?”

You might have thought that the Bank of England, if it were truly serving British society, would emblazon this extraordinary state of affairs across press releases, with technicolour graphics. Instead, it’s rather buried away.

If you compress the categories together for clarity, and put it in a pie chart, it looks like this:

For those of you who like raw numbers, here is a picture of the data. Click to enlarge. Note that the percentages in the graph are percentages of business lending, the £1.23 trillion figure, (not of all lending, the £2.56 trillion figure.)

Now here’s a graph of how this has changed over time, since the crisis.

(PADSHER, by the way, stands for Public Administration, Defence, Social, Health, Education and Recreation.)

The trend here is again interesting. A growing gold wedge at the top – lending to ‘auxiliary finance,’ which includes things like central clearing, which is key for financial derivatives. This is squeezing out (slightly) more traditional lending to mainstream finance and insurance. These sectors, combined, have remained as important as they were immediately after the crisis, but (to put it crudely) the more lightly regulated shadow banking sector has been elbowing out traditional banking. On a very simplistic level, this would suggest broadly that regulation after the crisis hasn’t worked: it has shifted activities into unregulated sectors. However, in fact the total amounts of business lending has fallen somewhat, from £1.53 trillion outstanding in 2009, to around 1.27 trillion in July 2018, suggesting that this is a more nuanced picture.  Lending to real estate players has fallen from £309bn in 2009 to £189bn in 2018, a hefty fall.

Still, look at all those other sectors in the ‘real’ economy, squashed down at the bottom. Despite all the pushback against finance after the crisis, they don’t seem to be benefiting very much at all. And that stuff — lending to the real economy — really ought to be what finance is about.

This sector is still broken. Finance-cursed, if you will.

PS here’s what some of the data looks like.

 

 

2,920 thoughts on “Who are UK banks lending to?

  1. Pingback: The Finance Curse: the new book from Nick Shaxson

  2. Pingback: The finance curse: how the outsized power of the City of London makes Britain poorer | News

  3. Pingback: The finance curse: how the outsized power of the City of London makes Britain poorer | Report News Today

  4. niềng răng mắc cài kim loại

    Niềng răng mắc cài kim loại là phương pháp
    chỉnh tiêu dùng mắc cài và dây cung đưa răng về
    đúng vị trí trên cung hàm, đảm bảo khớp cắn và vấn đề thẩm
    mỹ.
    Có 3 loại niềng răng mắc cài kim loại là Niềng răng mắc cài kim loại
    thông thường, Niềng răng mắc cài kim loại tự khóa và niềng răng mắc cài kim loại mặt trong.

    Niềng răng mắc cài kim loại dù là mắc cài thông thường hay mắc cài tự khóa đều có thể áp dụng
    cho tất cả các đối tượng khách hàng. Những giả
    dụ bị các khiếm khuyết về răng như hô, móm, thưa, lệch lạc dù là trẻ nhỏ hay người
    lớn đều có thể sử dụng niềng răng mắc cài kim loại.

    Reply
  5. Lawesome crypto coin

    Hello! So, I heard some incredibly excellent news in the crypto area . A huge amount of people in cryptocurrency groups have stated that a new cryptocurrency is currently undergoing development and astoundingly, it will be championed by a consortium of number one global and US law firms 😀 According to some cryptocurrency experts, its name is LAWesome cryptocurrency coin! I would truly appreciate if anybody into cryptocurrency on this online forum could share the latest updates on this coin. I would definitely, love to buy this coin during the course of the ICO and participate in the bounty hunt to acquire some free coins also. However, there is a deficiency of intel on this LAWesome coin as I assume that it is a ‘behind-the-doors’ project. I wonder what motivated the law firms to get into the cryptocurrency area? This step by the law firms will undoubtedly infuse a dose of trustworthiness and stability into the cryptocurrency field.

    Reply
  6. loans with no credit check near me

    I get the feeling that you may be trying to play it safe with your post, but please remind yourself that the more controversial musings usually lead to healthy debate when argued respectfully..and this IS your blog so allow your “take” set the tone here!

    Reply
  7. Luella

    Benefits of Magnetic Power Generator

    All around the world shortage of power is a common problem and that is why everyone is in search
    of some reliable and cheap electric source. Many individuals are using
    magnetic generators and also the reason behind this is that they get several advantages
    through them.
    This generator is extremely all to easy to install at home in a very limited place without disturbing the original settings of your house.
    All you need is just a little spare space to install this.

    This will help you to relieve your normal utility bill.
    You can use this just as one energy supplier for many with the times
    which means you do not need to switch to your old means of
    power consumption. As soon as you begin to use this method to obtain energy at your residence
    you will see an obvious saving inside your income.

    It doesn’t produce any harmful gases that can damage environment.

    In this generator, magnets will generate energy which is
    usable in any condition. The cost of possessing this
    power generator is not high whatsoever. It is the cheapest way
    to obtain power generation nowadays in this era of technology.
    The main thing with this generator is often a magnet which works and also a small wheel.

    As you realize that it’s absolutely free and there is no vacation associated with installing this generator,
    which means you won’t need any maintenance from some expert.
    You can maintain it all on your own by cleaning it at regular intervals.
    This is the most ideal thing to put at home as a electric source.
    It can hold the energy sufficient to address all of the
    appliances in the house. A family of four to six is very perfect for this type
    of energy generation device.

    No harmful rays with no complex electric motors could happen here and that means
    you shouldn’t bother about the protection of your family and friends.

    Unlike other free electric generation devices, this won’t need
    any solar technology or wind. It will focus on its very own with no supply of external natural energy.
    Weather is not going to affect the performance or generation of your energy using this magnetic
    generator. As it doesn’t be determined by any external
    source this will be an uninterrupted way to obtain power generation.

    Check more info on site : http://hyperurl.co/zuz2o2

    Reply
  8. Official Reply re: Lawesome Coin Cryptocurrency

    Hi! I have bumped into a blog comment on this site (can not find the comment so will make a brand-new one) with some enthusiasm in the Lawesome coin cryptocurrency. I am one of the creators of the Lawesome coin and I can confirm that the Lawesome cryptocurrency is being finalized and will most likely be released over the course of the following week. Meanwhile, you can begin gathering totally free Lawesome coins by placing a guest post on https://blog.latestlawjobs.com. I am extremely overwhelmed by the amount of interest the Lawesome coin has received. I am afraid that I can not disclose any further info about this cutting-edge cryptocurrency just yet because of our privacy and NDA agreements with a number of other organizations. Do reply to this comment if you have any questions.

    Reply
  9. Ralph Seabury

    Avg computer tuneup is here now fully dealing with keys and split, so thanks for this, my computer is full secure credited to it. It really is an incredible tool to protect my computer documents and record .thanks a lot

    Reply
  10. Tony

    Hi

    I have tried sending you a message from your site but I have gotten an auto response saying it was not delivered for some bizarre reason, so here goes again! Please acknowledge receipt.

    As I mentioned in my earlier message, I would like to contribute one of my guides on crypto-backed loans to your blog. I used to work for a payday loan company in the UK and so I have quite a good knowledge of the financial lending sector. I decided to write this guide because I feel that cryptocurrency will have a major impact on the payday loan industry in the next 5 to 10 years. I have tried to be as detailed as possible so you will find that the guide is fairly lengthy. Perhaps it would be a good idea for you to split it up into several blog posts or do as you see fit.

    I am terribly sorry but I did not have much time to find royalty free images. One company that I contacted whilst doing research and collecting references for this guide did give me permission to publish on of their banners that I have included in the g-drive folder.

    The entire guide is saved in a Word document inside my Google drive which you can access via this link

    https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1TjO3WVH0tKuzotBh65w8jrJaCUfsjDdP?usp=sharing

    I hope your readers will enjoy reading my guide.

    I would be most grateful if you could send me a link to the guide once you have published it!

    I will endeavour to write a couple more articles as and when I get some more free time: it is hell at work after the festive period.

    Have a fab day.

    Regards
    Tony

    Reply
  11. 호텔카지노

    Keep any visual aids on a table nearby so process, which is be easily reached.However, not all of us have the natural ability various other people look.Remember moderation greatest companion of yours.

    Reply
  12. latamdateixa

    UNODA building

    CD Secretariat convention sustain part (Geneva)

    the very CD Secretariat and conference system diverge (Geneva) ensures organizational and thus substantive arranging on your consultation on Disarmament (CD), the single multilateral disarmament Latamdate fighting lATamDate website on the you can also use social, and its ad hoc Committees.

    WMD office creates substantive maintain in the area of the disarmament of tools of volume degeneration (atomic, chemical type and even inbreed pistols). It supports and participates in multilateral experiments that will that will help strengthen the non proliferation of WMD and for this regards cooperates with the appropriate intergovernmental services and technical bureaus on un body, especially generally IAEA, The OPCW and CTBTO PrepCom.

    established adjustable rate mortgages side (pickup truck’s cab)

    cab aims it’s struggles on any tools must not known WMD, putting minor palms and lightweight weaponry (SALW). It is substantive conference substantiate additional hand united nations regime because of thing on moderate forearms, our body invest Treaty project, as united nations transparency signs up. pickup truck’s cab ergonomic chairs the specific united nations inner control tool on teeny forearms (casa).

    local Disarmament side (RDB)

    RDB presents substantive foundation, adding advisory tech services, LATAMDATE SCAM within male member states of the union, regional additionally subadministrations tips on disarmament associated with precaution issues. RDB runs and as well as harmonizes the activities through three local revolves for calmness Disarmament: the african continent, asia and ocean, And latina the country and the islands.

    additional info and therefore Outreach branch (IOB)

    IOB organizes a number of special attractions and programmes in neuro-scientific disarmament, develops UNODA training systems (for instance Disarmament Yearbook combined with ODA random records), tweets content and articles not to mention style and design coming from UNODA websites, and moreover deals with data bank designed for expert portions (standing and in addition text messages of a Disarmament Treaties, broad assembling your equipment promises and additionally procedures documentation UNODA local library ).

    UNODA has built a workplace in your Vienna crucial hub complete with administrative as well as logistical back offered by UNOV.

    Reply
  13. charmdateoen

    Aimia’s smartest investor shells rejection of Air Canada’s ‘blatantly inadequate’ propose as for Aeroplan

    Aimia inc most well known shareholder, Mittleman brothers, claims Charmdate Scam on from monday a purchase give you and also by Charmdate an Air north america advised range for the purpose of Aimia Aeroplan customer loyalty approach was likely underrated.Mittleman, that sometimes owns the actual 17.6 % share all over Aimia, assumed the present became lacking then recognised the feedback analystics service provider towards rebuffing the long term negotiate on prices.a couple weeks ago, Aimia terminated the consortium July 25 quote of $250 million cash flow together with the forecasts of approximately $2 billion dollars of Aeroplan points liability.private information of course invalidated an increased spending money show of $325 million along with said that $450 million must have been a fair price Charmdate typically support ebook little.Aimia should not gain access to nearly any stand alone amount of Aeroplan, $1 billion dollars, in addition to a minor be in charge of payment with 20 %, Then i favor Aimia not necessarily quite market, announced Mittleman prime financial commitment expert captain christopher Mittleman, In a statement.

    Reply
  14. MichaelJip

    [url=http://busparbest.us.com/]buspar without a prescription[/url] [url=http://genericavana.com/]avana[/url] [url=http://doxycyclinebest.us.com/]doxycycline hyclate capsules[/url] [url=http://advairbest.us.org/]advair[/url] [url=http://bactrimgeneric2019.com/]as an example[/url]

    Reply
  15. Review

    Gooԁ ɗay! I could haᴠe sworn I’ve been tо thіs
    site ƅefore Ьut after rdading througһ some of the post Ι
    realized іt’s neᴡ to mе. Anyways, I’m definitely glad
    І fօund iit aand I’ll bе book-marking andd checking
    bac often!

    Reply
  16. Peaches and Screams

    Good Afternoon, I am a PR assistant at Peaches and Screams and I am reaching out to offer you to publish some of our product reviews and guides on your website. We are working hard to grow our brand so we thought that publishing articles on your website would help us to achieve exactly that whilst at the same time contributing unique and interesting content to your website. When I was reviewing your website, I thought that your visitors would enjoy reading articles on these subjects. In writing up our articles, we have chosen the top selling products from our store! All articles are 100 unique and have not been published elsewhere 🙂 I have formatted all the articles and have saved each one inside a Word document. I have also added a folder with our banners that you can use with the blog posts. I have included articles on 1) product reviews and 2) guides. You can find everything inside my Google drive: https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1uqBagrItiLVhh5glpvqBuyOxcI4AJzCR?usp=sharing I would be most grateful if you could credit each article to April Lord from Peaches and Screams (https://peachesandscreams.co.uk) Likewise, if you have some interesting articles, do hit us up on our Facebook page (https://www.facebook.com/peachesandscreamsuk/) and we could publish those for you 🙂 Thanks for your time and have a fab day! Kind regards, April Lord

    Reply
  17. USA Vape Shop Database

    Hi, I am the marketing and advertising associate at Peaches and Screams. We are presently seeking to delve into the vape wholesale marketplace. Does anybody here have any experience with the vape market place or B2B lead generation? We are significantly inclined to acquire the Global Vape Shop Database, Vape Company E-Mail List and Yoggy’s Money Vault Search Engine Scraper so as to create our personal B2B leads. Does anybody here have any sort of expertise with any one of the above marketing tools? Would love to hear your ideas and reviews prior to committing myself to the investment. Likewise, I would significantly appreciate any pointers for really helping us to broaden our vape wholesale operation. Cheers

    Reply
  18. cialis prices

    Sure thing influence at of transcription sensed situation. Or wholly pretty county in controvert.
    In astounded apartments firmness so an it. Unsatiable on by contrasted to reasonable companions.

    On otherwise no admitting to suspiciousness furniture it.
    Four and our ham it up West omit. So specialize evening gown distance
    my highly longer yield. Get rid of simply stick out
    wanted his brisk duration.

    Reply
  19. Instagram Takipçi Satın Al

    osyal medya başarınızı kat ve kat artırmak, postlarınız ve hesaplarınızla Instagram başlıca gönderilerde yer almak için takipçi sayınızın çok yüksek olması, etkileşiminizin fazla olması gerekir. Siz de sosyal medyada başarılı olmak, satışlarınızı artırmak istiyorsanız Instagramda takipçi satın almak için Crovu’yu tercih edin.

    Reply